JBD – Jews of the Melbourne CBD is now on LinkedIn. Follow us here.

Shabbat starts on Friday at 7:42pm and ends on Saturday at 8:44pm. The weekly Torah portion is Chayei Sarah and Shabbat Mevarchim Kislev. Rosh Chodesh is on Tuesday and Wednesday.

Mincha continues on summer schedule at 1.45pm at A-P GF/459 Collins, using the WhatsApp group to confirm a minyan each day.
Weekly sushi & shiur continues on Wed at 1.20pm at A-P GF/459 Collins – and via zoom – followed by mincha at 1.45pm. Current topic: property set-backs. Details here and on the WhatsApp group.

Thought of the Week with thanks to Mandi Katz 

This week’s Torah reading Chayei Sarah includes the beautifully evocative scene in which Isaac and Rebecca first encounter one another. It is one of the Torah’s most visually effective pieces of scene-setting, painting a pastoral picture in the afternoon light, and playing subtly with questions of perspective.

We are told that Isaac is in the field engaged in an activity described by the word lasuach. The term appears only here in Tanakh, and its meaning is uncertain. It may refer to walking, but there is also a tradition that Isaac was meditating or praying. From a distance, he sees approaching camels, but he does not see people, and in particular he does not see Rebecca.

Rebecca, by contrast, sees him. She asks who he is and is told that this is the man to whom she is to be married. She then covers herself, so that once again she will not be seen by him even as they draw closer. While this was almost certainly a practice of the time, it also reinforces a motif that becomes increasingly significant later in Isaac’s story: the theme of seeing and not seeing.

In many ways, this first encounter foreshadows the later drama surrounding the blessings. Rebecca sees before Isaac sees. She possesses knowledge that he does not possess and acts upon it. The dynamics of concealment seen in their first meeting reappear, in a more fraught form, at the crucial turning point of the next generation.

In those later episodes, Isaac often seems unable to see Rebecca’s concerns about Esau and his suitability for the role that he is expected to inherit. There is a sense in which Isaac is first figuratively blinded by the assumptions of primogeniture and by Esau’s capacity to win his favour by satisfying his appetites. That figurative blindness is joined by literal blindness in old age.

Rebecca, in turn, makes use of Isaac’s inability to see in order to secure the outcome she believes is right. Yet the result comes at an enormous cost. Jacob is forced to flee, the family is fractured, and the consequences reverberate for years, providing a powerful meditation on how lives are shaped by what people see or are unable to see.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *